nonprofit

The Grand Canyon Divide Between Successful and Struggling Charities

In the fundraising world, there is a definite major noticeable difference between the highly successful charities raising $100’s of $1,000’s of dollars, if not millions and those who either break even or raise very little. The difference is so large, it’s as if both are standing on different sides of the Grand Canyon.

 

The reason for the difference is based on these three criteria:

 1.       Time

2.       Resources

3.       Professional Fundraising Assistance vs. DIY Uneducated Fundraiser

 

Charity A – Successful

#1 – Time

A charity that has been established for many years has had ample chances to educate themselves on how to plan a successful fundraiser. They have gone through years of planning and executing their events. They have learned what works and what doesn’t. They have curated the right guests to attend and have had many years to educate everyone on the amazing work they are doing while showing social proof.

 

#2 – Resources

Over time, they have learned to build a fundraising infrastructure. They have created systems to identify high-level event sponsors and donors. They have procured a list of potential sponsors based on various surveys as well as being recognized in their community for the work they have done. Furthermore, they have held many fundraising events/galas and had time to educate their guests on how to spend and what their event entails. They have sought out Auction Item donors who can and do donate high-quality auction items for their live and silent auctions. They have learned from their guests in regard to what they like and will bid on.

 

#3 – Professional Fundraising Assistance

Routinely, successful charities will hire a “Director of Development” whose sole purpose is to plan, manage and run their upcoming fundraising activities such as Galas. These individuals are part of their paid staff and hired based on their professional experience as well as prior successes—they essentially hire their own Professional Fundraiser. The Executive Director of the charity knows that he/she does not have the time or knowhow to plan such an event; their focus is on handling the business of the charity and more importantly, its mission in the community in which it serves.

 

Charity B – Unsuccessful / DIY Uneducated Fundraiser

#1 – Time

A new or fledgling charity has not had the time to grow their base. Often they are solely volunteer-driven. They proudly proclaim “We are all volunteers,” meaning “We have no paid staff – our donations don’t pay salaries.” That statement in and of itself, unbeknownst to them, is actually detrimental to their success because it signals to other charities in the area that they aren’t competition. They haven’t had time to grow their base or to figure out how to plan a successful fundraising event. They haven’t learned what a successful fundraising event even looks like. Because they are volunteers, they do not have the time to devote their lives to the mission of the charity and how to raise more money.

 

#2 – Resources

Because they are “All Volunteers,” they don’t have the time to go out and meet potential sponsors and donors. They haven’t had the time to learn how to plan, manage, and host a successful fundraiser and often attempt to simply copy another fundraiser they saw from another similar charity. That is why these types of charities conduct “50/50” or “Money Wheel” raffles—which are not successful. They often rely solely on donated items, especially gift baskets for their auctions—because they haven’t had the time to evaluate whether those are effective. Often, after their fundraising events, they don’t even go back and study their event to see how to improve. Because they are “All Volunteers” living a full-time life, with a full-time job, with a full-time family and full-time commitments—they simply do not have the time needed to invest in the charity to help it grow.

 

#3 – DIY Uneducated Fundraiser

These charities are stuck because they have beliefs that greatly hinder their growth. Again, because they are “All Volunteer” (signaling that none of the funds raised go to pay salaries), they are against hiring a professional fundraiser—believing that if they pay someone to help with fundraising, it will take money away from their event, instead of increasing it. They do not have the time to educate themselves on successful fundraising trends, are not professional event planners, and do not know how to host a successful fundraising event. They falsely believe they can “Do It Yourself” and experience the same success as the much larger, more profitable charities. They have no clear direction planning the event—they guess on what to do next and what will help. They often focus only on the outcome of the event rather than the experience of the donor. They give away “Door Prizes” which local businesses donated to help raise money—but these are simply given away. They don’t understand event timelines, they make homemade flyers, and they don’t understand how important the venue is in appealing to major donors. They are simply guessing.

 

In Summary

The huge chasm between the highly profitable charities and the DIY Uneducated Fundraisers is rooted in the belief that “You must spend money to make money.” New or completely volunteer-driven charities must seek the help of a professional fundraiser—hired as a contractor—to help plan, execute, and teach them how to build a truly successful event.

 

Volunteer-led charities should not try to compete with larger, more experienced organizations or criticize them with comments like “Their Executive Director makes $100,000.00.” They don’t yet understand the importance of having a qualified professional in that role—and how much that person helps raise. Instead, they should focus on their own growth and mission—and seek help from a professional team like BW Unlimited Charity Fundraising. Contact BW today at 443.206.6121 or their website at www.BWUnlimited.com or by email at info@bwunlimited.com.

 

How to Host a Fundraising Event That Stands Out (and Sells Out)

Are You a Small or Growing Charity?

Let me ask you three quick questions:

  1. Is your nonprofit organization long-established with a large, paid staff?

  2. Do your fundraising events consistently secure over $100,000 in sponsorships?

  3. Are your event tickets priced over $200, and do you sell out every year?

If you answered “No” to all three, here’s what you’ve just admitted (even if it stings):

You’re likely a small or grassroots charity.

You may be volunteer-run or have little to no full-time staff.

Your event history is short, your support base is still growing, and your charity gala or dinner doesn’t yet attract deep-pocket sponsors or high-spending donors.

Your ticket prices are lower—not because your event lacks value—but because your audience can’t justify a $200+ commitment.

And that’s OK. But if that’s your starting point, you need to be crystal clear on what you’re up against.

📉 Tough Questions You Need to Ask:

  1. How many people attended your last charity event? Was it under 200?

  2. Is this your first fundraising dinner or benefit gala?

  3. Are you struggling to move tickets?

  4. Do you know how many nonprofit events take place in your region—or across the country?

Let’s talk numbers.

Know Your Competition: The Fundraising Event Landscape

According to the most recent data, there are 1.5 million registered 501(c)(3) nonprofits in the U.S.

Each year, Americans host 2 to 3 million documented fundraising events, and that doesn’t even count local benefit events thrown by community groups or individual causes.

Let’s do the math:

🔢 Fundraising Events per State:

Low Estimate:

2,000,000 ÷ 50 states = 40,000 fundraising events per state per year

High Estimate:

3,000,000 ÷ 50 states = 60,000 fundraising events per state per year

That's how much competition your nonprofit event is up against every single year.

🏟️ Imagine the Stadium...

Picture this:

You’re in an NFL stadium packed with 70,000 charities. The smaller, newer nonprofits—you—are seated way up in the nosebleeds.

Suddenly, 300 potential donors walk out onto the 50-yard line.

A countdown clock on the scoreboard ticks down to 0:00. The buzzer sounds.

Now every single charity in the stadium has 10 seconds to shout their mission and try to convince those 300 donors to pick their cause.

That is what you’re doing every time you promote your event with a homemade flyer, no clear message, and a boring title like “Charity Fundraiser for XYZ Organization.”

🚫 Stop Leading With Your Charity

Here’s the brutal truth: Nobody cares about your charity first—they care about the experience you’re offering. When people hear “fundraiser,” they assume it’s boring, overly serious, or a hard sell.

Don’t lead with your mission. Don’t open with your cause. Don’t make your flyer all about “helping people.” That comes later.

If you want people to show up, you have to sell them on the event.

What to Do Instead: Lead with HYPE

Your Event Needs:

  1. Excitement

  2. FOMO (Fear of Missing Out)

  3. A compelling, unforgettable hook

Whether you’re planning a fundraising gala, a community charity event, or a benefit auction, make the event sound like a night they’ll regret missing.

💥 Talk about the food, drinks, raffles, live music, silent auctions, and exclusive experiences.

🎟️ Use phrases like “limited seating”, “exclusive event”, and “VIP ticket options available”.

📲 Promote with bold, energetic visuals and compelling social media content.

📢 Save the Mission Talk for the Microphone

Once your event is sold out, the room is buzzing, and the energy is high—that’s when you tell your story.

THAT’S when people will care.

THAT’S when they’ll listen.

And that’s when they’ll give.

💡 Final Thought

If your nonprofit fundraising event is just another “flyer about a fundraiser,” you’re already drowning in the noise of 3 million other fundraisers.

But if you build excitement, use powerful event language, lead with entertainment value.

You don’t just stand out.

You sell out.

Unlocking Successful Charity Auctions: Dispelling Myths and Maximizing Bids

Welcome to the inaugural edition of Fundraising University! Today, we're tackling a pervasive myth in the realm of charity auctions: the necessity of listing retail values for auction items. Let's dive in and debunk this misconception once and for all.

In our quest to demystify charity fundraising practices, we consulted with our trusted Accountants, who diligently researched prevalent myths. One myth stood out prominently: the notion that listing retail values on auction items is essential. This belief, while widespread, is not rooted in reality.

Citing IRS Code 561, it's crucial to clarify that charitable donors are only entitled to claim the retail value, not the selling price, on their annual taxes. However, over time, this guideline has been misinterpreted, leading to the misconception that charities must disclose retail values to potential bidders.

With over 17 years of professional fundraising experience under our belts, we've witnessed countless instances where items with "known retail values" failed to meet expectations. Consider a recent Silent Auction scenario featuring two enticing items:

  • "Unique Experiences for Auction": A $1,000 Gift Certificate for a private jet experience.

  • "High-End Collectibles for Auction": A $500 Gift Certificate for a renowned cowboy boot company.

Despite their perceived retail values, the auction outcomes were surprising:

  • The private jet experience sold for $220.

  • The cowboy boot company certificate fetched only $200.

These results are not anomalies; they're a recurring pattern. Despite our best efforts to advise charities against listing retail values, many still do so, unaware of the unintended consequences.

So, what's the winning strategy for charity auctions? It starts with setting realistic starting bids or "Reserve Bids" and defining bidding increments. Moreover, organizations should curate auction items strategically, focusing on offerings that ignite excitement and evoke a "Fear Of Missing Out" (FOMO) among potential bidders.

Embrace items that offer exclusivity and allure, such as:

  • Celebrity Memorabilia for Auction

  • Luxury Items for Auction

  • Entertainment Packages for Auction

  • Travel Packages for Auction

  • Artwork for Auction

  • Home and Lifestyle Items for Auction

Remember, the key to success lies in understanding your audience and selecting items that resonate with their interests and aspirations. Dispel the myth that guests will bid based on retail values alone; instead, focus on creating memorable experiences that inspire generosity and support your organization's mission.

In conclusion, let's rewrite the narrative of charity auctions by prioritizing impact over perceived value. Together, we can elevate fundraising efforts and make a lasting difference in our communities. Stay tuned for more insights and strategies from Fundraising University!